‘Homebody’ Speech Riles Japanese Women

Print More

Mariko Mitsui 

TOKYO (WOMENSENEWS)–Mariko Mitsui, a former Tokyo assembly member and advocate for women’s rights, isn’t ready to accept the regrets of a government official for his comments at a women’s business summit here.

"Many women are upset and disgusted with his scandalous statements," she said. "He strongly wishes women should be at home. I am extremely ashamed to be Japanese that such a man still remains a vice minister in the government."

More than 300 businesswomen and other participates from the 21 member countries of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum listened on Oct. 1 as Yoshikatsu Nakayama, the ruling Democratic Party’s vice minister of economy, trade and industry, repeatedly said Japanese women enjoyed staying at home and holding the power behind the throne.

"Japanese women find pleasure in working at home and that has been part of Japanese culture," Nakayama told the meeting, which was co-hosted by Japan and the United States in the central city of Gifu. "They should be given more credit through (raising their husbands’) salaries, but it has become impossible as the situation surrounding men has become severe."

His quotes were printed in several Japanese newspapers, including the Mainichi, Kochi, Kitanihon and Kyodo News Agency.

Mariko Mitsui 

Minister’s Speech Spreads

News of the speech spread by word of mouth and through online social networking sites.

Fusako Okada, a nursery school teacher, heard about Nakayama’s remarks from a friend who read about it in the newspaper. She was so shocked that Nakayama made the comments in front of "gender professionals" from around the world that she formed an online protest group. Participants in several cities have been e-mailing the government with demands for his resignation, she said.

"The Japanese government’s policy is for equal opportunity for men and women and Nakayama publicly went against it," she said, referring to the country’s 1986 employment law.

Many women and several groups have protested by sending e-mails and some "certified forms" to Prime Minister Naoto Kan, Nakayama and the Gender Equity Bureau of the ruling Democratic Party of Japan demanding Nakayama’s resignation. Protest organizers include two major women’s advocacies–Working Women’s Group in Nagoya and Alliance of Feminist Representatives in Tokyo–along with the Fight-Back Association, an Osaka nonprofit that defends plaintiffs against illegal dismissals.

Mitsui said Nakayama has made other controversial comments in the past.

Controversial Past Comments

During an internal government debate about promoting gender equity in 2004, Nakayama was widely quoted as saying: "Man, should be manly, a father should be fatherly, a mother should be motherly, an elder sister should be elder sisterly and a young sister should be young sisterly. These roles make the family work well. When you keep these roles firmly at the family, your family won’t be involved in sex crimes."

He made the comments during the "Promotion of Forming the Gender Equal Society" debate at the Cabinet Committee of the Lower House, which is a standing committee.

Nakayama has told Kyodo News that he regrets the remarks made earlier this month, saying, "I would like to do what I can, albeit small, for women to play a greater role in business."

But that hasn’t stopped the pressure on him to step down.

Mitsui says the decision is up to Prime Minister Kan, who hasn’t made any comments on the issue.

In the meantime, Mitsui added it was important for women to continue sending e-mails to the government demanding Nakayama’s resignation.

Japan ranked 94 out of 134 countries in the World Economic Forum’s Gap Index 2010, a ranking of gender equality. Last year, a United Nations committee recommended that the Japanese government correct discrimination against women by reforming its systems of laws, employment and wages.

Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at http://www.womensenews.org/help-making-comments-womens-enews-stories.

Would you like to Send Along a Link of This Story?

Catherine Makino is a correspondent for Majirox News in Tokyo, Japan. She has written for the San Francisco Chronicle, the Los Angeles Time, the Japan Times, The Asian Wall Street Journal and Inter Press Service.

One thought on “‘Homebody’ Speech Riles Japanese Women

  1. The life that the Japanese government official wants is the old farm life, where mom and dad and children and grandparents were all in the same place, and divisions of labour were made by size and sex. Few people live this way, and what such men psychically deny, is that they are not the only people in a family whose lives have changed with education, technology, global awareness, and access to transportation. If he is serious about women staying at home, he needs to also be serious about men staying at home and being a farmer in his own backyard, so the family can be self-sufficient again, non-educated, local thinking and acting totally, and dedicated only to his family and possibly the family being dedicated to a local religion that helps make a small community work together. Otherwise, get over yourselves, men! I too, am worried about children, and especially the emotional health of young children, but to blame mothers for problems created by absent fathers is irresponsible in the extreme.