Arab Women in Revolution: Reports from the Ground

Part: 11

Libya Liberation Speech Raises Hackles on Polygamy

Friday, October 28, 2011

Libya's long-awaited declaration of liberation excluded female voices and raised questions about how the tide might turn on matters of family law. The country's interim leader faced immediate backlash for endorsing a return to unrestricted polygamy.

Page 2 of 2

'Disconcerting Signs'


"There have been disconcerting signs that women in Libya will have to fight for their place at the table," Gerntholtz told Women's eNews.

Among these signs, Gerntholtz noted the absence of women in the top ranks of the National Transitional Council, Libya's interim government that must oversee the country's transition to democracy, and in international meetings, including a major gathering that unfolded in New York in September to discuss a post-Gadhafi Libya.

While women were boxed off to the side during Libya's liberation speech this week, that itself was not particularly concerning. By custom women and men often gather separately, including during many of the protests that erupted Feb. 17 in the religiously conservative city of Benghazi.

The real source of alarm came from Abdul-Jalil, a former justice minister who defected early in the revolt and a devout Muslim, who now chairs the National Transitional Council. One of the things he endorsed when he took the microphone was unrestricted polygamy, which is curtailed under the current marriage law but permissible in Islam.

"Any law that violates Sharia (Islamic law) is null and void legally," he said in his speech, targeting the current law on marriage.


Abdul-Jalil also reiterated in his speech that the new Libya will turn to Sharia as the main source of legislation and emphasized that no law in contradiction with the Quran would stand. "The law of divorce and marriage . . . is contrary to Sharia and it is stopped," he said.

Backpedalling Clarification

That statement drew such outcry at home and abroad that Abdul-Jalil quickly backpedalled the next day, saying his comment on marriage was "just an example" and stressing that no laws had been done away with. The clarification, coupled with reassurances that Libyans are "moderate Muslims," was welcomed in the West where there is a rising concern that the Arab Spring heralds a new era of Islamist leaders, particularly in Egypt, Tunisia and Libya.

"We are encouraged to see President Jalil make a clarification," said U.S. State Department spokesperson Victoria Nuland. "The No. 1 thing is that universal human rights, rights for women, rights for minorities, right to due process, right to transparency be fully respected."

Libya's law of divorce, which in some Muslim countries requires no more than a man's statement or even a written SMS text message to his wife in order to be upheld in court, also contains certain provisions protecting women and their property. Both men and women can initiate divorce and have the right to keep their property when the marriage ends. But in the absence of statistics, it is difficult to measure the gap between law and practice.

"Under Gadhafi, there were no laws that were reinforced, except the ones that personally benefited him and his family," said Najla Aswad, a Libyan citizen living in Saudi Arabia. "As I live in Saudi Arabia, I know what it is like to live as a woman completely under Sharia law so I believe in order to move towards any form of democracy, we need to have a freely elected body that will start working on a constitution, and civil laws as a start."

Speaking Out Against Polygamy

Gadhafi, who married twice and was always surrounded by women -- be it his Amazonian bodyguards or Ukrainian nurses –spoke out against polygamy, a practice that occurs but is not widespread, according to Freedom House.

To take a second wife, Libyan law requires a man to "secure prior judicial permission based on the grounds of financial capacity. He must also obtain the written agreement of the first wife.

"Of all the problems Libya has faced in the last 42 years, the law on marriage was not one of them," said a female Libyan journalist living in Cairo. "The fact that he chose to highlight this particular topic on Liberation Day is mind boggling."

Some Libyans have argued that after the deaths of so many young men on the front--an estimated 50,000 were killed in the conflict--reinstating polygamy is a way to offer protection to the widows who were left behind.

"The state is responsible to look after these women," said the journalist, who requested anonymity because her job doesn't allow opinion on the region she covers. "Re-introducing polygamy is the state saying 'you are not my problem,' go find a man who will look after you. It's a complete regression of the status of women."


Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at

Would you like to Send Along a Link of This Story?

Dominique Soguel is a contributing reporter and managing editor of Arabic Women's eNews.

2 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments



Libyan Women Challenge Mindset Created by Tyranny

Cultual trends and popular culture

Journalist's Tweets Give Voice to Libya Uprisings

As one of the Libyan women said, '[this] mind-boggling". The rise in Muslim fundamentalism is exactly one of the concerns of the West in some of these uprisings. Women must now be very aware of how they may be pushed aside, and there has never been a time when women are more in need of each others' support in nations including Libya, as they reset their national standards, laws, and methods of education and policing. The United Nations and nations with strong laws and practices of women's rights must show definite support for these women!

You say: "Not a single woman was on the stage to take credit for her role throughout the revolution or to set the tone on matters of direct personal relevance to women, such as the needs of war widows or the Libyan family code."

Of course not! The overwhelming majority of women supporting the rebelion, esp. in Benghazi and Misrata, were doing so by subjection to their male relatives, they weren't fighting, they submitted, by tradition and kin, and they conform to the misogynous sharia...

The only women fighting even with their weapons in their hands, were those defending their homeland against NATO and their reactionary stooges.

All your fogging rhetoric to justify the NATO regime is sheer rubbish. You bought the propaganda and media lies to such an extent that you believe them!

Whatever you, Susan Rice, and Jalil say to dress the monkey in silk, it is still a monkey, in this case a disparate bunch of fanatic Islamists, former regime renegades, vicious looters and killers, and foreing mass murderers and thieves.

Libya has been raped to the bone, a prosperous country living in peace with everybody and respecting all its engagements has turned into a lawless land in the fist of armed gangs aided by ultratechnological foreign high-road robbers. It has gone 50 years backwards, and its citizens have lost their lives and wealth, their care and wellfare, their highest income and life expectancy in Africa, and now thanks to NATO, the fanatic Islamists, and the treacherous and lying global media, they have turned into pariahs.

So please stop persuading us that the rebels' and NATO's intentions were good but risk to go awry. They were not and they are not! They were precisely this, what happened! The return to the middle ages on the one hand, and the control and misappropriation of Libyan riches by the imperial powers on the other hand.


Part: 23

Egypt's Women Keep Showing Power in Protest

Part: 22

Egyptian Upholds Sex-War View of Revolution

Part: 21

Young Moroccans Keep Arab-Spring Spirit Alive

Part: 20

Iraq's Refugees in Jordan Live in Desperate Limbo

Part: 18

Human Rights Groups Blur Issues of Women Rights

Part: 17

Arab Women's Forum Presents Revolution 'Lite'

Part: 16

Egypt's Feminist Union Undergoing Reincarnation

Part: 15

Arabic Twitter Stars Come Face-to-Face in Cairo

Part: 14

In the New Tunisia, Women's Rights Are in Play

Part: 13

Libya Liberation Speech Raises Hackles on Polygamy

Part: 12

U.S. and Arab Women: Both Demand Democracy

Part: 11

Bahrain's Young Women Keep the Revolution Aloud

Part: 10

Lebanon Protesters Take Aim at Family Law System

Part: 9

Journalist's Tweets Give Voice to Libya Uprisings

Part: 8

Algerian Women Test the 'Arab Spring' Winds

Part: 7

Male Domination in Egypt is Only Half a Revolution

Part: 6

Cairo Women Stunned by Male Harassment at Protest

Part: 5

Zimbabwe Discourages Interest in Arab Uprisings

Part: 4

Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood Raises Sharia Question

Part: 3

Logan Attack Doesn't Brand the Entire Middle East

Part: 2

Cairo Leaders: Suzanne Mubarak Held Women Back

Part: 1

Egyptian Women Lay Claim to Revolutionary Role