Rebuttal: Biden Was Right About More Rape Policing

Friday, November 25, 2011

When Vice President Joe Biden recently argued that more police will help prevent rapes he said nothing amiss. And a change to the FBI's definition of rape is hardly trivial. For one thing, if affects the allocation of federal money.

Page 2 of 2

Next Steps

The next step is consideration by the FBI's Criminal Justice Information System Advisory Policy Board at its Dec. 6 public meeting in Albuquerque, N.M. The final step in the process is approval by FBI Director Robert Mueller.

We've worked in Philadelphia to reform police practices dealing with sex crimes and have consulted with journalists throughout the country who have uncovered scandals regarding sex-crime investigation.

We've learned that with strong leadership, collaboration with advocacy organizations and appropriate resources, police can improve their response to sex crimes. We've seen it in Philadelphia – we're not done here but we've made significant progress – and we're seeing it in other cities as well.

For 10 years the Women's Law Project, along with Women Organized Against Rape, the Support Center for Child Advocates and the Philadelphia Children's Alliance, have conducted unprecedented yearly reviews of police sex crime and child abuse files.

Murphy charges that rape victims "almost never call 911 because they rarely report the crime right away."

Our review of thousands of cases tells us otherwise. We know that child sex abuse rarely comes through the 911 system, but older teens and adult women make the call. It is well known that the response from the first police officer on the scene is critical to the outcome of the case.

The reality is that fewer police on the job means fewer police to respond to calls and to appropriately investigate incidents of sexual violence, which means less accountability for perpetrators and therefore increased crime and decreased public safety.

Resource-Intensive Crimes

Rape crimes are uniquely resource-intensive – and of special interest to Vice President Biden – so he singled them out because these crimes would be particularly affected. Instead of criticizing the vice president, Murphy should applaud him for keeping the issue in the public eye.

More significantly, however, the vice president has supported expanding the FBI's crime-report definition of rape because the current definition causes significant undercounting of sex crimes.

So the fact that there are even more sex crimes than the public and policymakers have known about means that the need for police is even greater than we thought, which is exactly what the jobs bill will address.


Murphy is correct that most women don't report their rape to police. But that does not mean those who do come forward should not receive appropriate police response. If the police are not responding, it is our job as advocates to call them to task.

More police and improved police response will, we hope, increase reporting by increasing public confidence in the police. It is clearly in the public interest to encourage increased reporting to law enforcement so that more rapists – who tend to be serial predators, according to current research – will be apprehended.

The vice president did not "throw the rape card." He raised public awareness of the crime of rape. His comments may have been somewhat inartful, but he nevertheless accurately described a major unmet need and a solution to it in the jobs bill.

Additional police clearly are not the only answer, but their role in fighting violence against women cannot be overstated.


Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at http://www.womensenews.org/help-making-comments-womens-enews-stories.

Would you like to Send Along a Link of This Story?

Carol E. Tracy is executive director of the Women's Law Project, a public interest law center located in Pennsylvania that is engaged in high impact litigation, public policy advocacy and community education on reproductive rights, violence against women, family law and family court reform and discrimination in employment and education.

For more information:

Women's Law Project:

Rape and Sexual Assault, Women's Law Project:

2 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments



Note to Biden: Cops Aren't Answer to Rape

You make some good arguments, but they address neither Ms. Murphy's points nor VP Bidens points.
VP Biden was being his normal self. He was defending a package that would hire thousands of police officers. His thoughts were no deeper than putting thousands of police officers on the street, and therefore prevent rapes. He's wrong.
Ms. Murphy makes this point... when was the last time a police officer prevented a rape in progress? They don't. He would have you believe that they do.
I think you're article should have targeted the the admistration gaffe artist. But... then you woud not have had your forum to expound on points that addressed neither Murphy nor Biden, but rather,your own agenda.

This is an important article on a very serious problem with the justice system, beginning with policing and ending with the courts. All need more emphasis upon ensuring justice for women who have been raped; that is to punish the rapists and to support the women who have been raped.