'Cougar' Women Say He Just Happens to Be Younger

Sunday, July 11, 2010

The cougar craze--of media interest in women with younger men--boasts a gallery of celebrities, books, TV shows, movies and mixed feelings. But in plenty of couples the dynamic is simple: He just happens to be younger.

Page 2 of 2

Echoing Cultural Misgivings

While the cougar craze may seem to help women fight the notorious loss of sexual status that comes with aging, it also echoes cultural misgivings about female sexuality.

Often people assume dating younger men is synonymous with promiscuity, Navarro said. People have made remarks about being "on the prowl" to her and to Sherry Eckert, a jewelry maker and yoga instructor in Seattle who has dated younger men. Not only were the remarks off-putting, they didn't even describe Eckert's experience. The men, she said, always approached her.

Media accounts describing these relationships often play up the supposedly predatory, implicitly desperate nature of such women. A 2008 New York Daily News article headlined "Rowr!" went on to say Kutcher "fell prey" to Moore.

The same judgments can befall non-celebrity couples. Spitznagel's mother had reservations about McBride until they met and she realized her future daughter-in-law "wasn't some scary, mini-skirted, high-heeled, club-hopping cougar."

"People see that stereotype and immediately think it's trashy and there can't be any meaning to the relationship," McBride said.

In an effort to combat those assumptions, much like the feminist reclamation of "bitch," author Linda Franklin coined the term "Real Cougar Woman" in her book "Don't Ever Call Me Ma'am." The term describes a middle-aged woman who's not afraid to "crash through glass ceilings," who takes care of her body and finances and who refuses to be defined by the man in her life.

Study Delves Deeper

Love stories like that of McBride and Spitznagel or Nelson and Cohen reflect a reality that isn't much discussed, according to Nichole Proulx-King, a marriage and family therapist in Maine. Proulx-King and Sandra Caron, a professor of family relations and human sexuality at the University of Maine, published a study in 2006 on age-gap relationships; they are expanding the study this summer.

So far they have surveyed eight married couples in which the woman is at least 10 years older than her spouse. In this tiny sampling they have found some general patterns. The women--more often than the men--are college-educated, focused on their careers and have had children. Most did not know the other's age when they were introduced.

Men generally appreciated the women's maturity, Proulx-King said.

Eckert told Women's eNews that the younger men who have sought her out seemed more comfortable than her peers with dating a strong woman. They liked the fact that she had produced her own yoga video and appeared on TV.

The survey found the age gap mattered more to other people than the couple themselves, who saw their relationship as akin to any other, Proulx-King said.

Pepi Parshall, volunteer services coordinator for the St. Louis Public Library, said her female friends' unanimous reaction upon hearing she was dating a man 18 years her junior was, "You go, girl!"

Her family was less comfortable with it. Parshall had a good job and house; they worried at first that her then-boyfriend was trying to take advantage of her. But family members have come around in the 12 years they've been married.


Claire Bushey is a freelance journalist based in Chicago.

Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at


For more information:


To participate in therapist Nichole Proulx-King and professor Sanda Caron's expanded study of older women and younger men, fill out the survey here:

Essay on "The 'C' word" by Susan McBride:

Linda Franklin's Web site, author of "Don't Ever Call Me Ma'Am: The Real Cougar Handbook for Life Over 40":

Note: Women's eNews is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites and the contents of site the link points to may change.

5 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments



For Better or Worse, 'Sister-Swapping' Persists


'Marry Him?' More Bad Advice for the Lovelorn


After Layoffs, Couples Wrestle With Role Reversal

Media Stories

'Sugar Daddy' Sites Push Line on Paid Sex

Crime Policy/Legislation

Cyberstalking Turns Web Technologies into Weapons


Online Matchmaking Sites Court U.S. Muslims


In India, Parents of Brides-to-Be Hire Sleuths

Love is Love. Be Happy.

I am all for it, however if this was a man who married a younger woman wouldnt most people say he was taking advantage of her. I guess we will all remain nutural on this issue now.

This is a great article that truly points out one simple is about diversity. In a world filled with billions of people, there is one soul-mate allocated to each and I am so blessed to have found mine.

Great piece and really balanced! Most "news" stories about older women/younger men cast the woman as a middle-aged floozy desperate for sex/attention. A lot of 40+ women I know are pursued by the young guys and not just guys who want to piggyback on the women's success/money/whatever! IMHO, we make *way* too much out of this when guys have been doing it for ages. Why can't it just be about two people wanting to be together??? Thanks for presenting another viewpoint on this.

"Her family was less comfortable with it. Parshall had a good job and
house; they worried at first that her then-boyfriend was trying to
take advantage of her."
-the above quote deals with a part of this subject that deserves much more scrutiny. Women, including possibly many readers of this article, are so nurturing in nature, we are making excuses for the men in such relationships, while not being as skeptical of them as men are of the women in these relationships; women did not invent the name 'cougar', it was male skepticism. It is legitimate for a woman's family to be skeptical of a younger man interested in an older, especially successful woman, he really benefits, he may be a man who is not prepared to do the 'together maturing', emotionally, financially, and as a couple, of a same-age couple, which is much more work. A couple of about the same age, one with the other, really do have to develop together. I do imagine the men who seek out older women wanting to set themselves up in life more easily than they would have to do with a woman their own age. I know I would worry about a sister or girl friend of mine who became serious enough about a younger man to marry him.