Selective Abortion-Ban Won't Stop Son Preference

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

A congressional bill to ban sex-selective abortions and those based on race--the so-called PRENDA bill--poses as a defender of gender equity and racial justice. Sujatha Jesudason says its real effect would be to undermine both.

Page 2 of 2

Intrusive Scrutiny

abortion rallyThis bill means one thing for every woman: the most intrusive scrutiny of the reason she seeks an abortion. And restricting women's rights and questioning their decision-making is an utterly misguided approach to promoting gender equality.

Our real challenge is to change the context in which sex selection occurs, addressing gender and racial equality issues while protecting the right of all women to make the best reproductive decisions for themselves and their families.

Some data show sex selection is occurring in the United States. The studies focus on Asian immigrant communities. In recent Generations Ahead research with South Asian American community members in the San Francisco Bay area, few participants reported knowing of cases of sex selection using abortion or other reproductive technology. What did trouble them was the widespread cultural preference for sons that they frequently experienced.

The South Asian American women in our study do not want to see legal restrictions. They firmly believe that the way to address the problem of son preference is to change social and cultural norms through community education and discussions. Restricting access to the different sex selective practices would not resolve the social and cultural roots of the practice.

In other countries, it should also be noted, bans have not worked as a way to stop son preference.

We believe the use of sex selective technologies reflects gender stereotypes that limit human potential, reinforcing unfortunate social and cultural norms. Changing that begins by encouraging prospective parents to question their own assumptions and expectations of their sons and daughters alike.


Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at http://www.womensenews.org/help-making-comments-womens-enews-stories.

Would you like to Send Along a Link of This Story?

Sujatha Jesudason is executive director of Generations Ahead, based in Oakland, Calif., which works with reproductive health, rights and justice organizations to ensure a social justice approach to reproductive genetic technologies. Generations Ahead works to discourage son preference norms that lead to sex selective practices through partnerships and engagement with South Asian American and Asian American community groups as well as health care providers, including fertility doctors.

For more information:

Generations Ahead:

NARAL calls it a race- and sex-based attack on choice:

0 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments


Reproductive Health

Parents Paint the Petri Dish Pink


Atlanta Ads on Black Abortions May Go National

Black Maternal Health of New York City

High Death Rate of New York's Black Moms Analyzed