Abortion

Abortion Suicide Link Fails a Court Test

Friday, September 30, 2011

An appeals court struck a suicide advisory from a South Dakota abortion law, underscoring decades of research finding no link between the procedure and mental health disorders. But the idea of psychological harm remains active in several states.

Page 2 of 2

34 States Require Counseling

Today, three of the 34 states that require counseling before an abortion mandate a warning of negative emotional responses. They are Michigan, Nebraska and West Virginia, says a report from the Guttmacher Institute, though only West Virginia mentions the risk of "suicidal thought or acts."

Three other states--Kansas, Texas and Utah--include mental health risks in their state-funded material, and both Texas and Utah include suicide and thoughts of suicide as a risk.

"We've seen the idea that mental health disorders are a risk of having an abortion over and over again in state legislation," said Nash. "Many times the debates are put to an end when legislators see that the research is not bearing out."

The possibility of a link between abortion and mental health disorders entered high-profile politics in 1987, when President Ronald Reagan asked then Surgeon General, C. Everett Koop--an outspoken opponent to abortion--to prepare a report on the psychological effects of the procedure. After reviewing 250 articles from the Atlanta-based Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Koop in 1989 declared an insufficiency of scientific evidence to make a comprehensive conclusion and would not publish the findings.

Seeking a more clear-cut statement, the American Psychological Association in 1990 commissioned a report by the journal Science, which concluded that women who have voluntary abortions do experience severe distress, but the majority of that occurs before, not after, an abortion.

"The weight of the evidence from scientific studies indicates that legal abortion of an unwanted pregnancy in the first trimester does not pose a psychological hazard for most women," the study said.

No Evidence

In 2008 a task force commissioned by the American Psychological Association again found no credible evidence "that a single elective abortion of an unwanted pregnancy in and of itself causes mental health problems."

Proponents of the South Dakota bill--the state and crisis pregnancy centers--relied heavily on studies by anti-choice researchers Coleman and David Reardon, said Jennifer Aulwes, media relations director of Planned Parenthood Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota, based in Minneapolis, in an e-mail.

"Their research has been discredited by leading professionals and organizations in the field," said Aulwes.

The connection between abortion and suicide crept into public education during the era of abstinence-only sexual education under President George W. Bush.

One curriculum, "Me, My World, My Future," taught teens: "Following abortion, according to some studies, women are more prone to suicide," according to the 2004 Waxman Report, commissioned by then California Rep. Henry Waxman.

"What's happened is that the anti-abortion movement has found people to put out methodologically flawed studies that allege that there is a problem with mental health after having an abortion," said Jessica Arons, director of the Women's Health and Rights Program at the Center for American Progress, a progressive think tank based in Washington, D.C.

Pregnancy crisis centers, where women are often encouraged or required to seek counseling before an abortion, may also warn women about the negative mental-health consequences. Because the centers aren't medical facilities, the information is often not regulated.

Subscribe

Would you like to Comment but not sure how? Visit our help page at http://www.womensenews.org/help-making-comments-womens-enews-stories.

Would you like to Send Along a Link of This Story?
http://www.womensenews.org/story/abortion/110929/abortion-suicide-link-fails-court-test

Maura Ewing is an editorial intern for Women's eNews. She is currently pursuing an M.A. in liberal studies at The New School in New York City.

For more information:

Court Ruling on the appeal:
http://www.keloland.com/ClassLibrary/Page/News/files/Abortion%20Ruling.pdf

3 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments

RELATED STORIES

Reproductive Health

States Attack Planned Parenthood on Funding, Regs

Reproductive Health

Planned Parenthood Clinic Adapts to Leaner Budget

Reproductive Health

Birth-Control Roadblock Just Might Clear in 2014

Our History

Hyde Amendment Woke Up the Activist in Me

Abortion

NYC Tests Brakes on Crisis Pregnancy Centers

Abortion

Baltimore Puts Heat on Crisis Pregnancy Centers

Reproductive Health

States Boosting Funds for Abstinence-Only Sex Ed

Does this mean that pregnant women must be told by their doctors that 13% of them will get post-partum depression? Or that 80% of new mothers experience the "lesser" form, often called "baby blues," as the realities of child rearing take hold? Shall women with more than one child, especially women without partners or without jobs outside the home, be informed that their chance of serious, incapacitating depression increases exponentially as the children grow?

How about the physical effects of pregnancy? In addition to the obvious physical changes in the body and the scarring from episiotomies or c-sections, 35% of mothers become incontinent after giving birth. 50% of mothers experience later stage consequences including unresolvable incontinence after 55. We won't even discuss how the pressure on women to look wonderful after giving birth makes all this even more stressful.

Will doctors be forced to tell mothers that their chances of financial security are hobbled by having children? That their relationships will become strained by the responsibilities of child rearing? That being a mother can be considered as part of their work evaluation?

What always amazes me when I read these articles is that they fail to mention the "research" done by the APA was done by Brenda Major, PhD, a major pro abort.

They also fail to contact organizations like Lumina, Silent No More, Operation Outcry and others who have thousands of post abortive women who would beg to differ with their finding through personal experience with abortion.

Stacy Zallie left her parents a note saying she committed suicide due to an abortion. How many others have taken their life without anyone knowing of a prior abortion? Abortion hurts countless women. It is time people began listening to us who have had them.

Well said, Theresa! The research upon which this change was made was inadequate, and once again not asking the people who themselves have had an abortion, or families of women who have suicided after an abortion. I hope no other states follow this unless and until more thorough attention is given to those actually involved.
There really does need to be more attention paid to the dilemma of women who feel an abortion is their only option due to impossible life circumstances if they had a child. Few are actually helping these women and girls, leaving them with little choice. Sometimes, a pregnancy is an enforcement of keeping a woman at home or in some other way at the mercy of a very humbling situation where the idea of personal empowerment is not possible for her.

Women's enews events

Visit Our YouTube Channel

Visit Our Bookshelf