By Aparna Pallavi
Monday, September 15, 2008
Aparna Pallavi used to have a different name. Influenced by other people in India who wanted to leave caste behind, she found a new name that meant she could also leave behind unhappy family memories and embrace an identity fully her own.
NAGPUR, India (WOMENSENEWS)--"Remember who you are." At 10, I could only wonder at what my mother meant by telling me that.
I was a child like any other, and what did hanging upside down from a bar in the park have to do with who I was? I wanted to hang upside down like all the other children, but my mother firmly believed that "who I was" did not, or should not do it. In the end, mother won, as she always did.
As I grew up, the hedges of who I was kept growing thicker and thicker around my life, cutting off my access to more areas of experience. I was a Bose: a last name which signified that I was Bengali, and I was upper caste. And being a girl--a "Bose girl"--just meant that the pile of "should nots" kept growing higher on my plate.
At 11, I learned that Bose girls do not cross their legs while sitting with elders. Why? It was just so. At 12, I learned that a Bose girl does not wear skirts or pants, only "salwar kameez," the baggy trousers and loose knee-length shirts that cover the neck to the ankles. But why salwar kameez, which is, after all, a garment from Punjab in western India, and not the saree, which is worn in Bengal? That brought me to two more "don'ts" for Bose girls: They don't contradict elders and they definitely don't use book learning to argue with them.
By the time I was 24, the prison hedge was fully grown. A Bose girl only wore clothes chosen by her mother. A Bose girl only liked long hair. A Bose girl appeared before house guests only to serve tea. A Bose girl could get a job and earn, but she could not spend an evening with friends or manage her own money.
Any resistance brought the standard answer: "You do whatever you like in your husband's house." If that was what it took to be free, then all I wanted was to find a husband and escape to his house. So I did what a Bose girl does not even dream of doing: I walked out of my parents' house without their consent and married a man who was from neither my caste nor my state.
My in-laws were ready with open arms and within a month of marriage--by which time I was also pregnant--I found out why. My husband was an alcoholic who had an alcoholic father, two schizophrenic siblings prone to violence and a mother who believed it was her moral right to leave the responsibility of "reforming" and "managing" the family to the daughter-in-law and spend the rest of her life doing religious pilgrimages.
Moreover, I was now tied to a new last name--Tambe--that was at the very top of the caste hierarchy. I was now a daughter-in-law, not a daughter, and the pile of "nots" became insurmountable.
The cherry on top was that my defiance of parental authority--to me a positive and independent choice--had labeled me with "runaway" status, permanently blotting my moral character. I was told I was to remain beholden to my in-laws for accepting and sheltering the "fallen" creature I was, despite the fact that I had a job, was earning as much as my husband and contributing more to the family.
In India the only crime worse than a love marriage is the failure to live it out. So for seven years I struggled--with a job, a daughter, sexual and financial exploitation, and violence--trying to keep on a face of normalcy and happiness and trying to live up to being a Tambe daughter-in-law.
In the process I went from utter bewilderment to hysteria to deep depression. After I nearly died from a bad case of meningitis, I knew it was time to do what I feared most: move on and face the world.
I moved with my daughter first to a rented house and then to my own house, dropped the dud desk job and rediscovered myself as a freelance journalist. After four years, I was my own person, living a reasonably successful life on my own terms.
It took me some time to decide what to do about my name. When I was first married and working for a newspaper, it had taken me almost a year to reconnect with my readers using my changed name. I told myself this time the result would have to be worth the trouble.
There were several options. I had a close friend, who was a tribal rights activist, who had stuck to the last name of her first husband because she was used to it, despite a second marriage. For me, the very idea was disconcerting.
I had once read a poignant article by an Indian female journalist who had divorced titled, "Hold on to your dad's name because dad won't divorce you." But I did not want to return to the fold of my paternal name either.
I was aware that in the heyday of the Sarvodaya movement in India in the 1970s--a reformist push to reduce inequality and social stratification, with caste restrictions a main target--many men and women dropped surnames that signified caste and replaced them with the first names of one or both parents, either in full form or as initials.
I had met quite a few of these women and heard their stories, a mixture of personal and socio-political concerns. A few people I know had dropped the last name altogether, content to be known by just their first names. But I was not comfortable with these options either.
Instead, I added a completely new name. Today my name is, as one German journalist wonderingly put it, "two first names instead of a first name and a last name." My first name, Aparna, attributed to a Hindu female deity, means "leafless." My new last name, Pallavi, is the opposite, and means "full of leaves" in Sanskrit, Bengali and Hindi.
Years earlier, a rare and understanding individual whom I regard as my spiritual mentor had given me a special, private name just for me--Pallavi--and explained its significance. It was like a gift because it always reminded me of the healing effect this person had on me.
At last, at 35, I had become free of the tyranny of the caste-based last name. My name is now fully my own, a name not conditional to whom I live with. A name signifying to me aspiration rather than a preconceived framework to live up to.
Two years later, I married again, with no name change. It was the first time I went through a significant milestone in life without significant changes in personal circumstances. It was a relief not to have to go through a pile of name-change paperwork. It was a relief to go on being known by my own name, to know that I will be known by my own name till the end of my life.
Aparna Pallavi is a freelance journalist based in Nagpur and writes on development issues. She was a recipient of the National Foundation for India Fellowship for the year 2007.
By Juhie Bhatia
By Ann Marie Cunningham
By Léa Bouchoucha
By Hajer Naili
By Anna Halkidis
By Rita Henley Jensen
By Anita R. Johnson
By AWWP commentatore
By Jess McCabe
By Diane Kiesel
By Rosalind C. Barnett and Caryl Rivers
By Rita Henley Jensen
By Eryn Ashleigh
By Cyrille Cartier