She Works Hard for the Money

Part: 1

10-Hour Day Is Brief for a Home Health Aide

Thursday, January 19, 2012

What's it like to work in one of the most female-dominated occupations? Amy Lieberman kicks off our series with a day in the life of a home health care worker outside New York. Vicky Talag loves her work but doesn't feel right asking about a raise.

NEW YORK (WOMENSENEWS)--Vicky Talag's 15-minute morning drive to work ends at a two-story house in the comfortable suburb of Westchester, N.Y., just after 8 a.m.

She lets herself in, creeps through the dimmed foyer and points to the staircase. "She's still asleep," the 52-year-old whispers.

She bustles around the white-wallpapered kitchen, sweeping mail off the table and plugging in the coffee pot. Talag then darts upstairs to wake her employer, an 83-year-old woman who wants to remain anonymous in this piece.

Bookmark and Share

When Talag returns, she sits and slices prescription pills with a pill cutter. As she works, she talks about her job here as a home health aide, which she held since 2009.

Until a few weeks ago she worked five days a week, with days often stretching to 12 or 15 hours.

"I'm supposed to work 10 hours a day, but I often wind up doing more than that," Talag says. "But I need to act like I am taking care of my mother."

Talag has so far received no overtime pay or raise in this position, after almost three years. She hesitates to bring up these issues with her employer, who has suffered a series of health setbacks.

"If she is happy with me it is up to her to increase my pay. I want to ask her, but it isn't always the right time," Talag says. "When I brought her home from the hospital, I couldn't let her stay alone, so I stayed with her here. But I am stretching myself."

One week at the end of December, Talag worked a 24-hour shift. The next day, she felt exhausted and broke down crying. Then she took the next day off. She rarely uses her sick or vacation days, but when she does, an independent geriatric care manager arranges a replacement.

Rising On-the-Job Stress

Like Talag, an increasing number struggle with on-the-job stresses.

Health care support workers who required days away from work because of nonfatal occupational injuries and illnesses rose 6 percent from 2009 in the United States to 283 cases per 10,000 full-time workers in 2010, according to the U.S. Department of Labor.

Talag recently asked her geriatric care manager to change her schedule, to eliminate her Monday hours.

Now she will work Tuesday-Friday, 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. She says her employer didn't take the news very well at first, but has come around to the idea of change.

"Four days is enough for us to be together," she says.

Relatively well off compared to others in her field, Talag's contract--drawn up between her and her client--gives her five paid sick days, five holiday days and a two-week vacation annually. She covers her own health insurance.

The median hourly wage earned by home, care and personal assistance workers in the home health care industry was $9.40 in 2010, according to Paraprofessional Healthcare Institute National, a New York-based research and policy organization that promotes quality direct-care jobs.

That income lumps these workers "in the same category as teenage babysitters when it comes to how much they make," U.S. President Barack Obama said in a White House press conference at the end of December, when he announced a plan to extend the Fair Labor Standards Act, which grants minimum wage and overtime pay to these workers.

Talag earns more than minimum wage but is not willing to say publicly how much more, except that she is not paid for the hours she spends beyond what the contract calls for.

Her income, combined with that of her partner, allowed the couple to purchase their Westchester house and live comfortably, for the moment.

If Talag were to lose her job, though, she believes incorrectly she would be eligible for unemployment insurance and disability payments because she pays her taxes as a self-employed individual.

4 COMMENTS | Login or Sign Up to post comments


Equal Pay/Fair Wage

Times Haven't Changed for 'The Help' of Today

Equal Pay/Fair Wage

New York Nannies Prepare for Historic Job Protections

Equal Pay/Fair Wage

Women's Work Is Critical to National Jobs Recovery

Strong woman right there. The new federal regulations that will be implemented in 2015 will help benefit Vicky greatly. She will finally receive her overtime pay that she deserves.


i put my hat off for Vicky Talag, her desire to help people and building good relationship with her employer without worrying about the salary is really amazing.

Ashley J. Shaw

Vicky Talag's motivation is laudable—to do a good job and build business relationships—and is indicative of the sacrifice health care workers make in their own personnel lives on a daily basis. But care should extend to herself and her family and she should take necessary actions to plan for her savings and retirement.

Jill Tucker RN
Jill Tucker Nursing Services

As Vicky Talag's story shows, home care workers can work long hours without overtime pay. This is because they are not covered by the Fair Labor Standards Act. Readers can show their support for providing basic labor protections for home care workers by going to and following comment instructions. Vicki Talag would be covered by these rules if she were a housekeeper. Certainly, keeping her client strong, healthy and independent deserves the same level of respect and legal protection.


Series Overview

She Works Hard for the Money: Spotlight on Women's Working Lives

Part: 11

Retail Manager Stressed by 'Never Enough' Sales Strategy

Part: 10

RN's Pay is Fine, But Her 'Back is Killing Her'

Part: 9

Cosmetics Saleswoman Faces Ugly Risk of Bankruptcy

Part: 8

Bookkeeper Is Over-Booked But Not Raising Fees

Part: 7

Few Female Day Laborers Try Jobs in NYC Cleanup

Part: 6

Live-In Nanny Couldn’t Find Household to Call Home

Part: 4

Waitress's Wages Leave Little to Take Home

Part: 3

Office Manager Keeps $100,000 Pay Check in Sight

Part: 2

'Part Time' Cleaner Survives by Constant Work

Part: 1

10-Hour Day Is Brief for a Home Health Aide